11964 · Shelter Island, NY market pulse
Mar–May 2026
Not enough sales for a score
4 sales in these 3 months; scores need 10.
Sold above list, last 12 months
Sold above list
0%
▼ −33.3 pts vs. last year
Median days on market
176
▲ +19 days vs. last year
Median sale price
$3.24M
▲ +66.0% vs. last year
Median $/sqft
$781
▼ −33.9% vs. last year
Data:
Redfin
, Mar–May 2026.
Powered by BindingOffers